Tov Rose (The Happy Theologist)

Tov Rose (The Happy Theologist)

Share this post

Tov Rose (The Happy Theologist)
Tov Rose (The Happy Theologist)
How Jewish was the early Church?

How Jewish was the early Church?

Tov Rose
Nov 07, 2017
∙ Paid

Share this post

Tov Rose (The Happy Theologist)
Tov Rose (The Happy Theologist)
How Jewish was the early Church?
Share

Written by Knut Hoyland

Caspari Staff Nov 3, 2017

"The Disciples Admire the Buildings of the Temple" by James Tissot (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

In Matthew 15, we read the story of Jesus meeting a Canaanite woman. After initially dismissing her pleas for help, Yeshua (Jesus) ends up healing her daughter and acknowledging the woman’s faith. As one of the few encounters between Jesus and non-Jews recorded in the gospels, this passage has been interpreted as providing a model for the relationship between the Jewishness of the early Jesus movement and the predominantly Gentile Christian church which emerged in the post New Testament era.

Today we speak of Judaism and Christianity as two separate and distinct religions. It is true that the Messianic movement challenges this distinction by reconciling faith in Yeshua with Jewish identity, even making it a natural consequence of that identity. However, for most of the world, Judaism and Christianity remain two clearly different religions. The que…

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Tov Rose
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share